I have seen a few opinions about Les Miserables from--the best movie
ever to too dark. And after visiting the theater yesterday, I can
understand both remarks. Les Miserables is a dark story to begin with.
However with all the expectations, many were predisposed that it was
going to be the best ever even before seeing it. I wave watched the ten
year, and 25 year anniversary concerts over and over. And granted
those were concerts not theatrical productions but they music from
those far surpasses that in the movie. The movie was going for
character and story, and took the risk of casting theatrical actors in
musical parts. Sometimes it worked, and others it didn't. So the
pluses and minuses.
Hugh Jackman as Jean Valjean worked. His singing does not compare to
Colm Wilkinson, but he carried the roll. "Hear my Prayer" is the
highlight of the show, and although I would have liked to hear Colm
Wilkinson, Jackman delivered the emotion of the song such as to be
effective. It is just so beautiful the way Wilkinson holds that last
note.
Russell Crowe as Javert did not work. The song "I Swear by the Stars"
sounded more like some one singing in the shower than a prayer to the
stars. Crowe did make the suicide scene more believable than I had
seen it.
The added song of Valjean singing his love to Cosette added depth to the
character. You also can love instantly. Being a foster/adoptive
parent I know this is true.
The three young people, Cosette (Amanda Seyfried) Eponine (Samantha
Barks) and Marius (Eddie Redmayne) were the highlight of the show. They
carried their trio and other performing parts with energy and gusto. I
left the theater humming "heart full of love." "On My Own" was also
well done. However keeping with the dark theme of the director, was
done in the rain. Marius sang "Empty Chairs," with such beauty and
emotion, I think everyone who has seen this has cried with him.
Fantine (Anne Hathaway) was somewhat of a controversy. Lea Salonga
sings which much greater skill, energy and professionalism. However, in
the mood of the film, Hathaway did an incredible job. The song "I
Dreamed a Dream" was presented later in the movie, after arriving at the
bottom, rather than just starting the slide, so there was a different
tone (darkness) to the song. I especially like her in the death scene
at the end.
The innkeepers are a welcome comic relief. The must have worked so hard
at coordinating everything. I especially like their entrance through
the carriage to the wedding.
So there are more things to like and love about this version of Les
Miserables than there are to dislike. The music is worth going to see,
the action is well done, the characterization is good, and the sets are
effective (except for the sewer which is over the top) and the theme
that when we show love to each other, we show love to God is timeless.
Oh Colm Wilkinson does have a cameo as the priest. His baritone voice
resonates, and somehow he is in the final scene at the pearly gates. A
nice touch. I recommend this movie, but don't go so far as to say it is
the best ever.
I would not recommend this movie for children.