It isn't Steinbeck's writing style which I dislike. He is a master of this craft. However, in his efforts for realism, with some of these stories he leaves a sour feeling. It seems the stories are generally tragic, and sometimes too graphic.
The story which most left me with an eerie feeling was "Flight." You have a premonition it is not going to turn out well. Even the main character's sister, early on says her brother is not dead yet. It is just too graphic for me in the end.
"The White Quail" is also tragic. However in this case, the ending is unexpected, and very sudden. The wife in this story is very selfish in her pursuing a garden, above all else; above love for her husband, above having children, or letting her husband have a dog.
Steinbeck introduces us to later themes. A story deals with migrant workers ("Breakfast.") Another about labor organizing, ("The Raid.") He has a story about a man who at one time would had been considered an "idiot savant." (I think that label is offensive, but it works in this case.) "Johnny Bear" had no social skills, but had an ability to repeat conversations word-for-word. He uses this skill to get people to buy him whiskey. Going around as a human tape recorder, can only offend others and get you in trouble. Such is the case here.
Another story which leaves a bad feeling is "Murder." This story seems to indicate there is a place for spousal abuse. I totally disagree with this premise. There is never an excuse for hurting another of Heavenly Father's children.
Steinbeck also has a study of group think in "Vigilante." There have been studies of this. How people will sometimes do things they normally wouldn't, if they are going along with a group. In this story, we see a young man after he has participated in a lynch mob. There is no thought of their own guilt, but only justification and getting away with it.
This book does have the quality of writing of Steinbeck. However, I am not sure if all of these stories needed to be told.
No comments:
Post a Comment